[[Jamie Kennedy]] mengatakan kepada ''iFMagazine'' ditahunpada tahun 2008 bahwa dia dalam perbincangan untuk kembali memerankan [[Daftar karakter serial Scream#Randy Meeks|Randy Meeks]]. Mengesampingan fakta bahwa karakternya sudah meninggal di ''[[Scream 2]]'', Kennedy berkata "I actually had a conversation with somebody very big in the organization, and there's a way. I don't know what's going to happen, but they have plans for a lot of things. You can see new faces you wouldn't expect and you can see old faces that you wouldn't believe. There's a way to bring a lot of things around."<ref name="IFMagazine"/> Williamson melanjutkan dengan membantah banyak rumor yang beredar sejak ide kembalinya Randy (Meeks.red), dengan berkata bahwa Randy sudah meninggal dan tidak bisa dihidupkan lagi. Dalam ajang penerimaan [[Golden Globe Awards]], pasangan Arquette memberikan kemungkinan kembalinya mereka dalam ''Scream 4'' dan juga [[Neve Campbell]].<ref name="MTV"/>
Pada sebuah wawancara pada 23 April 2010 dengan FEARnet, WIlliamson mengkonfirmasikan bahwa tiga pemain inti ([[David Arquette|Arquette]],[[Neve Campbell|Campbell]], dan [[Courteney Cox Arquette|Cox]]) akan kembali dan membantah bahwa Kennedy akan kembali dan berkata "I would love nothing more than to have Jamie Kennedy in the film. However to have Randy in the film, it sort of just takes it… I mean Scream 2 was a lie, you know? It's a false move. So I just won't do it. I can't do that. I just won't do it".<ref name="FEARnet"/>
