| Tahun
|
Pemenang dan nominee
|
Film
|
Peran
|
| 1996 |
Armin Mueller-Stahl |
Shine |
Peter Helfgott ‡
|
| Steve Buscemi |
Fargo |
Carl Showalter
|
| Robert Carlyle |
Trainspotting |
Francis "Franco" Begbie
|
| Jeremy Irons |
Stealing Beauty |
Alex Parrish
|
| John Lynch |
Moll Flanders |
Jonathan (the Artist)
|
| Paul Scofield |
The Crucible |
Thomas Danforth
|
| 1997 |
Burt Reynolds |
Boogie Nights |
Jack Horner ‡
|
| Billy Connolly |
Mrs Brown |
John Brown
|
| Danny DeVito |
The Rainmaker |
Deck Shifflet
|
| Samuel L. Jackson |
Eve's Bayou |
Louis Batiste
|
| Robin Williams |
Good Will Hunting |
Dr. Sean Maguire †
|
| 1998 |
Donald Sutherland |
Without Limits |
Bill Bowerman
|
| Robert Duvall |
A Civil Action |
Jerome Facher ‡
|
| Jason Patric |
Your Friends & Neighbors |
Cary
|
| Billy Bob Thornton |
A Simple Plan |
Jacob Mitchell ‡
|
| Tom Sizemore |
Saving Private Ryan |
Mike Horvath
|
| 1999 |
Harry J. Lennix |
Titus |
Aaron
|
| Tom Cruise |
Magnolia |
Frank "T.J." Mackey ‡
|
| Michael Caine |
The Cider House Rules |
Wilbur Larch †
|
| Doug Hutchison |
The Green Mile |
Percy Wetmore
|
| Jude Law |
The Talented Mr. Ripley |
Dickie Greenleaf ‡
|
| Christopher Plummer |
The Insider |
Mike Wallace
|
| 2000 |
Bruce Greenwood |
Thirteen Days |
John F. Kennedy
|
| Jeff Bridges |
The Contender |
Jackson Evans ‡
|
| Benicio del Toro |
Traffic |
Javier Rodriguez †
|
| Robert De Niro |
Men of Honor |
Billy Sunday
|
| Albert Finney |
Erin Brockovich |
Edward L. Masry ‡
|
| Joaquin Phoenix |
Gladiator |
Commodus ‡
|
| 2001 |
Ben Kingsley |
Sexy Beast |
Don Logan ‡
|
| Jim Broadbent |
Iris |
John Bayley †
|
| Billy Crudup |
Charlotte Gray |
Julien Levade
|
| Ed Harris |
A Beautiful Mind |
William Parcher
|
| Ian McKellen |
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring |
Gandalf ‡
|
| Goran Visnjic |
The Deep End |
Alek "Al" Spera
|
| 2002 |
Dennis Haysbert |
Far from Heaven |
Raymond Deagan
|
| Jeremy Davies |
Solaris |
Snow
|
| Viggo Mortensen |
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers |
Aragorn
|
| Paul Newman |
Road to Perdition |
John Rooney ‡
|
| Alfred Molina |
Frida |
Diego Rivera
|
| Dennis Quaid |
Far from Heaven |
Frank Whitaker
|
| 2003 |
Djimon Hounsou |
In America |
Mateo ‡
|
| Alec Baldwin |
The Cooler |
Shelly Kaplow ‡
|
| Jeff Bridges |
Seabiscuit |
Charles S. Howard
|
| Benicio del Toro |
21 Grams |
Jack Jordan ‡
|
| Omar Sharif |
Monsieur Ibrahim et les fleurs du Coran |
Ibrahim Demildji
|
| Ken Watanabe |
The Last Samurai |
Moritsugu Katsumoto ‡
|
| 2004 |
Christopher Walken |
Around the Bend |
Turner Lair
|
| David Carradine |
Kill Bill: Volume 2 |
Bill
|
| Jamie Foxx |
Collateral |
Max Durocher ‡
|
| Alfred Molina |
Spider-Man 2 |
Otto Octavius / Doctor Octopus
|
| Clive Owen |
Closer |
Larry Gray ‡
|
| Peter Sarsgaard |
Kinsey |
Clyde Martin
|
| 2005 |
Danny Huston |
The Constant Gardener |
Sandy Woodrow
|
| Chris Cooper |
Capote |
Alvin Dewey
|
| Jake Gyllenhaal |
Brokeback Mountain |
Jack Twist ‡
|
| Edward Norton |
Kingdom of Heaven |
Baldwin IV dari Yerusalem
|
| Mickey Rourke |
Sin City |
Marv
|
| Peter Sarsgaard |
Jarhead |
Alan Troy
|
