| Tahun
|
Pemenang dan nominee
|
Film
|
Peran
|
| 2000 |
Benicio del Toro |
Traffic |
Javier Rodriguez
|
| Mark Ruffalo |
You Can Count on Me |
Terry Prescott
|
| Billy Crudup |
Jesus' Son |
FH
|
| Almost Famous |
Russell Hammond
|
| 2001 |
Steve Buscemi |
Ghost World |
Seymour
|
| Russell Crowe |
A Beautiful Mind |
John Nash
|
| Tom Wilkinson |
In the Bedroom |
Matt Fowler
|
| 2002 |
Daniel Day-Lewis |
Gangs of New York |
William "Bill the Butcher" Cutting
|
| Adrien Brody |
The Pianist |
Władysław Szpilman
|
| Nicolas Cage |
Adaptation. |
Charlie dan Donald Kaufman
|
| 2003 |
Sean Penn |
Mystic River |
Jimmy Markum
|
| Ben Kingsley |
House of Sand and Fog |
Behrani
|
| Bill Murray |
Lost in Translation |
Bob Harris
|
| 2004 |
Jamie Foxx |
Ray |
Ray Charles
|
| Paul Giamatti |
Sideways |
Miles Raymond
|
| Liam Neeson |
Kinsey |
Alfred Kinsey
|
| 2005 |
Philip Seymour Hoffman |
Capote |
Truman Capote
|
| Terrence Howard |
Hustle & Flow |
Djay
|
| Heath Ledger |
Brokeback Mountain |
Ennis Del Mar
|
| 2006 |
Forest Whitaker |
The Last King of Scotland |
Idi Amin
|
| Leonardo DiCaprio |
The Departed |
William "Billy" Costigan, Jr.
|
| Ryan Gosling |
Half Nelson |
Dan Dunne
|
| 2007 |
Daniel Day-Lewis |
There Will Be Blood |
Daniel Plainview
|
| Emile Hirsch |
Into the Wild |
Christopher McCandless
|
| Viggo Mortensen |
Eastern Promises |
Nikolai Luzhin
|
| 2008 |
Sean Penn |
Milk |
Harvey Milk
|
| Frank Langella |
Frost/Nixon |
Richard Nixon
|
| Mickey Rourke |
The Wrestler |
Randy Robinson
|
| 2009 |
Colin Firth |
A Single Man |
George Falconer
|
| George Clooney |
Up in the Air |
Ryan Bingham
|
| Jeremy Renner |
The Hurt Locker |
SFC. William James
|
