| Tahun
|
Pemenang dan nominee
|
Film
|
Peran
|
| 2000 |
Benicio del Toro |
Traffic |
Javier Rodriguez
|
| Jack Black |
High Fidelity |
Barry
|
| Willem Dafoe |
Shadow of the Vampire |
Max Schreck
|
| Albert Finney |
Erin Brockovich |
Edward L. Masry
|
| Philip Seymour Hoffman |
Almost Famous |
Lester Bangs
|
| 2001 |
Steve Buscemi |
Ghost World |
Seymour
|
| Ben Kingsley |
Sexy Beast |
Don Logan
|
| Jude Law |
A.I. Artificial Intelligence |
Gigolo Joe
|
| Tony Shalhoub |
The Man Who Wasn't There |
Freddy Riedenschneider
|
| Jon Voight |
Ali |
Howard Cosell
|
| 2002 |
Dennis Quaid |
Far from Heaven |
Frank Whitaker
|
| Chris Cooper |
Adaptation |
John Laroche
|
| Willem Dafoe |
Auto Focus |
John Henry Carpenter
|
| Alfred Molina |
Frida |
Diego Rivera
|
| Paul Newman |
Road to Perdition |
John Rooney
|
| 2003 |
Tim Robbins |
Mystic River |
Dave Boyle
|
| Sean Astin |
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King |
Samwise Gamgee
|
| Alec Baldwin |
The Cooler |
Shelly Kaplow
|
| Benicio del Toro |
21 Grams |
Jack Jordan
|
| Peter Sarsgaard |
Shattered Glass |
Chuck Lane
|
| Andy Serkis |
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King |
Sméagol/Gollum
|
| 2004 |
Thomas Haden Church |
Sideways |
Jack
|
| 2005 |
Mickey Rourke |
Sin City |
Marv
|
| Matt Dillon |
Crash |
John Ryan
|
| Terrence Howard |
Crash |
Cameron Thayer
|
| Paul Giamatti |
Cinderella Man |
Joe Gould
|
| Jake Gyllenhaal |
Brokeback Mountain |
Jack Twist
|
| Donald Sutherland |
Pride & Prejudice |
Mr. Bennet
|
| 2006 |
Jackie Earle Haley |
Little Children |
Ronald J. McGorvey
|
| Ben Affleck |
Hollywoodland |
George Reeves
|
| Eddie Murphy |
Dreamgirls |
James "Thunder" Early
|
| Jack Nicholson |
The Departed |
Frank Costello
|
| Brad Pitt |
Babel |
Richard Jones
|
| Michael Sheen |
The Queen |
Tony Blair
|
| 2007 |
Javier Bardem |
No Country for Old Men |
Anton Chigurh
|
| Casey Affleck |
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford |
Robert Ford
|
| Philip Seymour Hoffman |
Charlie Wilson's War |
Gust Avrakotos
|
| Hal Holbrook |
Into the Wild |
Ron Franz
|
| Tom Wilkinson |
Michael Clayton |
Arthur Edens
|
| 2008 |
Heath Ledger (posthumous) |
The Dark Knight |
The Joker
|
| Robert Downey Jr. |
Tropic Thunder |
Kirk Lazarus
|
| Philip Seymour Hoffman |
Doubt |
Romo Brendan Flynn
|
| Bill Irwin |
Rachel Getting Married |
Paul
|
| Michael Shannon |
Revolutionary Road |
John Givings, Jr.
|
| 2009 |
Christoph Waltz |
Inglourious Basterds |
Kol. Hans Landa
|
| Peter Capaldi |
In the Loop |
Malcolm Tucker
|
| Woody Harrelson |
The Messenger |
Kapt. Tony Stone
|
| Christian McKay |
Me and Orson Welles |
Orson Welles
|
| Stanley Tucci |
The Lovely Bones |
George Harvey
|
